Return to CreateDebate.commrshagmannace • Join this debate community

Mrs. Hagmann's Ace Debate


Debate Info

85
92
Change Offensive Mascots Leave as is
Debate Score:177
Arguments:55
Total Votes:225
Ended:12/21/15
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Change Offensive Mascots (22)
 
 Leave as is (33)

Debate Creator

chagmann(38) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Mascots

Change the names of mascots that might be considered offensive

Change Offensive Mascots

Side Score: 85
VS.

Leave as is

Side Score: 92
Winning Side!
5 points

People could get hung up on it and in 1972 it has been pretty tense from Stanford University

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
katielong(2) Disputed
3 points

but people's mascots are not about race or disrespect. The Redskins' attorney Lanny Davis said that "The mascot is not about disrespect, or race."

Side: Leave as is
4 points

"Mr. Cooper, a full-blooded American Indian, said his daughter became so offended, her eyes filled with tears and she asked if they could leave."

That is why it should be changed because it can be very offensive to some people.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
4 points

there are several teams who choose their mascots in a positive way, rather than negatively though.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
4 points

I agree with this because sometimes people will choose their mascot because they think it stands for their school and not because they try to be mean to that culture

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
Laney(12) Disputed
4 points

If schools don't realize that the mascot is racist the only way they are going to know unless they are told and then they can fix it in another way then getting rid of the mascot.

For example they could change the look of their mascot or maybe how their mascot acts at school games more to be respectful to the culture of the people offended

Side: Leave as is
Lukeasaurus(9) Disputed
3 points

Or the mascots can intimidate the other team rather than be offensive

Side: Leave as is
Lukeasaurus(9) Disputed
2 points

Sometimes schools don't realize that their mascot is racist

Side: Leave as is
Sloth_Sloth(1) Disputed
4 points

This is a bad thing because there was a story of a cheerleader who was wearing a headdress with feathers, doing flips and entertaining the crowd. What she didn't know, was that each feather represents a person who has lost their lives in battle. This is a disgrace to the Native American culture.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
Laney(12) Disputed
3 points

That is why you tell the school there is a problem you have with the mascot

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
ojacobs(1) Disputed
2 points

Even though the mascot offended the girl, it didn't seem that they were trying to offend the Indians.

The girl just simply did cartwheels and non offensive things. I don't think the girl had any intention to offend anybody.

Side: Leave as is
4 points

I think that mascots should change because it can be racist. People got offended by the names Redskins, and some got offended because of their culture.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
4 points

I think people just shouldn't be able to have anything that could possibly be offensive just so that it doesn't create anything between people

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
3 points

Because they racist and that ain't right.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
Laney(12) Disputed
4 points

They are not meant to be racist the mascots are meant more to honor not offend

Side: Leave as is
6 points

The Indians can be offensive to people who are Indian and shortly after the school changed their mascot too something non offensive then there was a 1,200 person protest that was made

Side: Leave as is
Sloth_Sloth(1) Disputed
4 points

How are these cultures being honored? Most of these team names are racial slurs that we don't know. If you look back at American history, Native Americans and other non-Americans were shamed by the pilgrims. This is something that still goes on today.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
Isabella1234 Disputed
3 points

Some people can take in offensive though because of there culture.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
4 points

I agree that people should change the mascots who offend any Native Americans. There was a story about a girl who started to cry because it was so offensive to her, this shows that people should really consider the feelings of other people and change the mascots that aren't respectful to Native Americans.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
Laney(12) Disputed
6 points

I think that If people are offended that they can take it up with the school board and the school can find a way to make it so that no one is offended.

Side: Leave as is
4 points

It isn't only Native Americans. Muslims and African Americans are also being offended.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
Kat234(2) Disputed
2 points

The girl in that story was crying because of the feathers on the cheerleader. That is a small part that can easily be changed. There is no need to change the mascot, because if you did that, more people would just be upset. What we need to do is change the tiny parts that are racist, not the parts that are fine.

Side: Leave as is
4 points

I agree that they should change offensive mascots. Trademark Trial and Appeal Board ruled that the word “Redskins” is “disparaging to Native Americans,” a violation of federal law that prohibits the use of offensive language in a trademark.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
3 points

Some mascots in sports offend individuals, and groups alike. This is why they need to change mascots before more people are offended.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
3 points

I agree. To go along, there is one story of a girl who was at a football team and she was very offended when a cheerleader from the opposing team came out with a feathered headdress. People don't know that the feathers represent battles people have been in.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
3 points

"When Samuel Henry was a kid growing up in D.C. in the late 1950s, he and his friends were devoted Washington Redskins fans — they had the jerseys and knew the lore. And as the lore had it, the “reddish-brown tint” of paint on the team’s downtown D.C. headquarters came from the blood of Native Americans. “When I was a kid, me and my friends, we really thought that they had captured and killed Native Americans and pasted them all over the building,” Henry said. “We were just kids, we didn’t know any better. But we really, honestly believed that.”" quote from http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-2128-native-american-mascots-people- arent-talking-about/ but the names of the mascots can be very offensive, but some people don't realize that they are offensive until they meet someone that it was offensive to.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
Laney(12) Disputed
2 points

I do not understand what you are trying to say in that paragraph

Side: Leave as is
4 points

School mascots can be respectful and show pride. Example some Native American view mascots as a source of pride.

Side: Leave as is
2 points

Not all people that are Native Americans that see a Native American sport teams mascots are offended lots think that it is more of a good thing like it gives them pride because there heritage is the fierce mascot of a sports team

Side: Leave as is
4 points

If schools don't realize that the mascot is racist the only way they are going to know unless they are told and then they can fix it in another way then getting rid of the mascot.

For example they could change the look of their mascot or maybe how their mascot acts at school games more to be respectful to the culture of the people offended

Side: Leave as is
3 points

You should leave schools' mascots alone because if there is something offensive being said or done, and it forces the school to change their mascots, it jeopardizes donation money, says ebsco.com.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

Team mascots were selected by high school teams to honor the past in a positive way. High schools with so called, offensive, mascots, don't get complaints right away, and they are never directly to the schools. Usually, the politicians are getting the complaints and it is after a while, says tri-cityherald.com.

Side: Leave as is
mgreeninger(12) Disputed
2 points

Yes I understand that school's mascots can honor the Native Americans but you really need to ask the Native Americans if they are okay with it because a lot of Native Americans are offended by the schools mascots.

Side: Change Offensive Mascots
katielong(2) Disputed
1 point

That just means that the mascots need to be more clear whether the mascots are offensive or not, and they need to show that it is in honor of them, rather than offensive.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

When we all read the story with the girl and her father being offended by the mascot they were not offended about the fact that the mascot was and native american but what the cheerleader was doing to represent the mascot. so schools should just change how they are representing the mascot

Side: Leave as is
3 points

Keeping the imagery honors the Native American people, and saves funding. Research has shown that some people support the use of Native American athletic imagery, says uncw.edu.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

Sports teams usually have a mascot because they think that person/animal/thing is fierce. Usually they don't mean to offend/make fun of their mascot but to kind of honor it.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

I think even though people are offended by mascots, a lot of fans would be offended if we changed the mascots. They aren't trying to be offensive by being fans of a certain team, the are trying to honor them and show pride in that team.

Side: Leave as is
1 point

Yes exactly I think that people would be offended if the mascot was to change but If it doesn't change other people will be offended so if we change the look not the character or how they act so that everyone is happy so the mascot will be representing what they are but in a different way so that no one is offended

Side: Leave as is
2 points

I think that mascots are ok because the team name can represent their team. Example: The Texas Longhorns name themselves that because bulls have horns, and bulls are a fierce animal/

Side: Leave as is
2 points

The majority of people think we should keep them, and the whole world shouldn't change just because a small group of people thinks something is wrong. The mascots aren't meant to be offensive anyway. People choose their mascots because they respect them or admire them.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

I wouldn't say it in that way but more of how instead of changing the mascot but changing the idea of the mascot the school is representing that people find offencive

Side: Leave as is
2 points

According to cnn.com a lot of people are not trying to be offensive. Mascots can be part of a school's culture and may sadden some people if they are changed.

Side: Leave as is
2 points

Even though that girl was offended and it might offend some other people, if we do change the mascot some people might be angry because the mascot is part of their history.

Side: Leave as is