Return to CreateDebate.commrshagmannace • Join this debate community

Mrs. Hagmann's Ace Debate


Debate Info

87
68
Raise the Driving Age Leave as is
Debate Score:155
Arguments:87
Total Votes:235
Ended:12/21/15
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Raise the Driving Age (45)
 
 Leave as is (37)

Debate Creator

chagmann(38) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Driving Age

Proposal: change driving age from 16 to 18. 

Raise the Driving Age

Side Score: 87
Winning Side!
VS.

Leave as is

Side Score: 68
3 points

I think that the driving age should be raised, because kids need to be more experienced. Safe Teen would provide the law of getting a learners permit at the age of 16, and a full license at 18. A car can be a more deadly weapon than a gun or knife.

Source http://teacher.scholastic.com/scholasticnews/indepth/upfront/debate/index.asp?article=d0508

Side: Raise the Driving Age
2 points

Agreed, kaden gave us good reasons that actually make sense. Plus, he also gave us a source, no other person has given us a source yet than Kaden! :D Good job Karen! :D

Side: Raise the Driving Age
RkDg_Crayon Disputed
-1 points

That us a good idea but 16 year old need a way of travel for example is would be very weird if a boy had his mom drive him and his GF to places.

Side: Leave as is
SCM26(2) Disputed
2 points

well... Teens need to learn responsibility first before they go out into the real world to survive by themselves. They need training!

Side: Raise the Driving Age
2 points

Each year, about one-third of deaths of teens are due to teens that are just starting to drive. This would decrease if the driving age was raised. I found this on the documents that Mrs. Hagmann provided.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
2 points

Raising the driving age will prevent accidents and death. 16- year old drivers cause more accident per highway mile more than any other age group.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

In 2005, four teenage boys were in a car accident where it spun out of control. Two of the four teens died after hitting multiple objects. The driver survived.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
RkDg_Crayon Disputed
1 point

But then 18 year olds will have higher crash per a mile.!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: Leave as is
RkDg_Crayon Clarified
0 points

If we raise the age they're still going to be inexperienced at driving and there going to be just as skilled at driving as 16 year olds are.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
RkDg_Crayon Disputed
-1 points

Really where did you get those facts from??????????????????????

Side: Leave as is
Banks(1) Disputed
1 point

These are exactly the same documents that you were given. Looking on them would have given you more counter claims.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
2 points

16 year old's have more accidents than any other age group. Raising the driving age will put more mature people on the road increasing the safety and cutting out one of the many reasons that accidents are on the road.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
2 points

Guys, nobody is experienced in driving and there will be all those gangsters who drive cars so the age needs to be raised

Side: Raise the Driving Age
21crajchel(6) Disputed
1 point

that dos not make any sense and if the driving age is raid what will that help

Side: Leave as is
2 points

At age 16, most people are not fully mature. Many teens do not realize that their reflexes and hand-eye coordination skills are not fully developed yet, and they can end up getting in accidents. This is why they should raise the driving age

Side: Raise the Driving Age
21crajchel(6) Disputed
1 point

so this will mean the same fo.r 18 year olds, this will only delay the crashes and cause more deaths for 18 year olds

Side: Leave as is
2 points

If the driving age was raised to 18, roads would be safer and teenage death rates from car accidents would be lower. All that we have to do is raise the driving age for safer roads and safer teenagers. Imagine everyone you know that died from a teen crash, coming back to life

Side: Raise the Driving Age
MELONLORD(9) Disputed
1 point

Actually no all you would be doing is delaying the death of your kids instead of 16 it might be 18!

Side: Leave as is
2 points

In New Jersey, they allowed teens to drive at 17. Studies have shown that the rate of teens killed in crashes in New Jersey has been lower after the driving age was too lowered.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/09/09/teen-driving-age-should-b n125010.html

Side: Raise the Driving Age
2 points

In 2008 there were more than 37,000 people killed on highways and more than a hundred people died every day because the Teenagers are being too irresponsible by running red lights. Teens are also getting way too distracted by talking on the phone and texting on the phone while behind the wheel.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

37,000 people were killed in a year by car crashes, and taking away teen drivers which are 3 times more likely to crash would take away lots of deaths. Comparing this to the vietnam war, it would take 3 of the deadliest years of the war to match the deaths of one year of highway driving. Thats a lot of deaths

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

All 50 states prohibit 16-year-olds from drinking alcohol, buying cigarettes, and purchasing handguns. Yet somehow most states are willing to put them in charge of a car, which could potentially be a deadly weapon. This could be be very dangerous

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

Teens in New Jersey have to wait to drive until they are 17, and there are fewer accidents there than any other state.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

All on one after school drive, the radio is blasting, phones are endlessly ringing and vibrating, and four teenagers are eagerly and distractingly chatting about whatever life or death situation occurred in between sixth and seventh period that day. This normally would not be a problem, for an experienced driver capable of blocking out distractions with the necessary focus skills needed that only time and practice can perfect. Yet, with an inattentive 16 year old who recently received their license behind the wheel, the lives of all four teenagers become more at risk with every inch traveled down the pavement by that car.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
2 points

If we start our learners permit at 16 and get our full license at 18, teenagers would have more experience on the road, and it won't cause as many accidents.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
MELONLORD(9) Disputed
1 point

No actually it wouldn't really do anything because you would still have 2 years of experience.

Side: Leave as is
1 point

Statistics have shown one of every five 16-year-olds will be in a severe motor vehicle crash within two years of getting their license- and that number is only rising- yet only for drivers 17 years old and younger. At 18, the rate of crashes drastically declines. The radical but now new idea of raising the legal driving age is most assuredly a controversial issue, and is gaining momentum, but if the lives of over 5000 teens lost in the year 2009 to motor vehicle crashes can’t convince America of the desperation in this cause, what will?

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

The driving age needs to be raised because of all the immature people. Sure it may not be fair to the kids who are experienced but the world will be a much safer place if we don't have teens drive until 18. Nobody wants to go to the hospital, or lose a loved one.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

Teen drivers like to be more dangerous than older adults. This can lead to high speeds, and drag races. This interferes with others trying to drive places, putting there lives in danger

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

Teens can impact the world with their immature stupidity when it comes to driving, put 'em in a simulator

Side: Raise the Driving Age
RkDg_Crayon Disputed
1 point

Well if schools taught kids on how driving is dangerous they might pay more attention.

Side: Leave as is
1 point

There are around 5,000 teenager deaths from crashes each year.

In 2003, 937 16 year old lives were lost in motor vehicle accidents. 411 were operating the vehicle. The other 352 were the passengers to drivers under the age of 18.

Source http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/09/09/teen-driving-age-should-b n125010.html

Side: Raise the Driving Age
RkDg_Crayon Clarified
1 point

We all make mistakes if we make the driving age higher then they will crash. We could set up a program where 16 year olds can drive only so much.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

Safe Teen would provide the law of getting a learners permit at the age of 16, and a full license at 18. This would make drivers more experienced on the road, and they would be more aware of things that could happen like falling trees and a lot more.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

Most crashes are caused by young teenagers, young and reckless, teens do not know how to drive properly without instructions, and even then are can still be a hazard! D:

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

Lives are at stake, a teenager could easily not know how to drive, and that could be dangerous. Nobody wants to pay for an accident that they didn't cause, and nobody wants to lose their own life

Side: Raise the Driving Age
0 points

If teens aren’t allowed to drink or smoke, then why do they have the responsibility to drive a car? With a car, they can kill other people and themselves. They can cause a lot of damage to the road, or things along it too.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

Also, traffic accidents are the leading cause of death for American teenagers, accounting for about 1/3 of all deaths in that age range

Side: Raise the Driving Age
4 points

Teens lack a maturity level of responsibility, they should raise the driving age guys,

Side: Leave as is
3 points

just like crayon said the fact of the matter is driving is based on experience and being able to make good choices. Sixteen-year-old drivers crash mostly because of inexperience.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

raising the driving age is not only just a bad idea, it does absolutely nothing to help except for delay death for only a short time.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

changing the driving age will cause more problems than it will help.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

It will cause more problems than it will help. but I get that you don't want to die early but changing the driving age really is doing anything but take away experience.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

It will cause more problems than it will help. but I get that you don't want to die early but changing the driving age really is doing anything but take away experience.

Side: Leave as is
3 points

Because the drivers get more practice at 16 and are more reliable at 18. They learn what they need to do in an Emergency.

Side: Leave as is
2 points

I think that raising the driving age will not help. Driving is more about expectorants 18 year old who just started are just as likely to get into accidents as first time 16 year colds driving.

Side: Leave as is
2 points

If the driving age is raised then 18 year olds will also crash because of inexperience. This means that the death rate of 18 year olds will increase, while the death of 16-year-old death rate; will increase. We are not helping the cause by raising the driving age we are just delaying the time they will die.

Side: Leave as is
2 points

If the driving age is raised then 18 year olds will also crash because of inexperience. This means that the death rate of 18 year olds will increase, while the death of 16-year-old death rate; will increase. We are not helping the cause by raising the driving age we are just delaying the time they will die.

Side: Leave as is
2 points

How mad would parents be if they have to drive their kids to all their events. Kids don't want to drive to practice, dances, or even just school. It would also definitely make parents mad.

Side: Leave as is
Banks(1) Disputed
2 points

Parents will have to drive students around more, but they will realise that it is so that their kids won’t die and think differently about it. Also, they must remember when they were younger and the same things happened to their classmates when they were starting to drive.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
kadenkemp(6) Disputed
2 points

MelonLord says that that they should leave the driving age as it is, but I say we shouldn't, because there could be more accidents when you are younger. 16 year old are not allowed to drink or smoke, but a car could be more deadly than drugs or a gun. Kids could get in a lot of trouble for doing something bad in a car. Therefore I think that the driving age should be raised.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
2 points

Parents are too busy to drive there 16 year old's to the mall or to meet with friends.

Side: Leave as is
1 point

The fact that people think raising the driving age is good is stupid. It's not because they're 16 that they are getting in accidents it's because they have a lack of experience.

Side: Leave as is
Dank_Shrek Disputed
2 points

Although you think that it is caused by lack of experience, raising the driving age after high school (Most kids graduate) will change a kid because they had to persevere through the hardest time in there life. Giving kids the chance to drive after they have matured over the hardest years in there life so they will know that they need to stay safe on the road.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
Robb(2) Disputed
1 point

But if kids aren't allowed to buy cigarettes, purchase handguns, and buy alcohol which are all things that can kill you, why would you trust the teenagers in the hands of a car which can potentially kill you

Side: Raise the Driving Age
21crajchel(6) Clarified
1 point

because its not like all that its just driving and not killing and positioning your self.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
RkDg_Crayon Clarified
0 points

Nice idea, if we raise the age they still we be inexperienced they could set up a harder driving course so they can be more EX.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

If the driving age is raised then 18 year olds will also crash because of inexperience. This means that the death rate of 18 year olds will increase, while the death of 16-year-old death rate; will increase. We are not helping the cause by raising the driving age we are just delaying the time they will die.

Says: A.J. ROX

Side: Leave as is
kadenkemp(6) Disputed
1 point

There will still be some crashes, but there will be less accidents than 16 year old.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
SCM26(2) Disputed
1 point

I don't agree with you Will, If you raise the age then their will be more experience and a lot less deaths because they have become more mature as they get older

Side: Raise the Driving Age
21crajchel(6) Disputed
1 point

how will they get that experience if there not driving, because if you don't do it you can't be experienced in it.

Side: Leave as is
Dank_Shrek Disputed
1 point

You may think that it is inexperience but it also comes with responsibility and maturity so high school will change a immature teen to an educated adult, so would you rather have the teen and the road or the adult.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
1 point

Teenagers need to be able to drive themselves to there jobs instead of relying on there parents

Side: Leave as is
1 point

How are busy 16 year old's supposed to get to places? The thing is they have to drive to practice drive to friends house or even drive to there boy friend or girl friend. It would be a huge inconvenience for the parents to have to drive all over the world.

Side: Leave as is
1 point

They say "that the driving age should be raised."

But "it lets be free and lets them feel good.

Because "it can also teach them to be responsible."

I think "driving age should stay."

Side: Leave as is
1 point

Teens need to be more responsible , and shouldn't always rely on their parents to drive them everywhere, your parents aren't you chauffeur.

Side: Leave as is
1 point

experience is the main cause of car wrecks for teens.If we change the minimum age to eighteen, they will have just the same amount of experience, (Learning for approximately a year and a half before license) age plays no factor into this. Yes, there can be others such as media distractions, peer passenger distractions etc. But most of the time, a sixteen year old could have just as much discernment as an eighteen year old. There will, of course, be irresponsible sixteen year olds, but there will also always be irresponsible eighteen year olds too.

Side: Leave as is
0 points

if we raise the driving age to 18 their still going to be inexperienced. That means that we're just delaying their deaths. 16 should be the driving age that way kids can get to high school easier and go to practice and such also their still getting experience in driving so then they can learn how to drive more safe at a young age.

Side: Leave as is
Banks(1) Disputed
2 points

Some might say that the deaths will then be moved up to age 18 but that wouldn’t be true because they will realize that if the age has been raised once for bad actions, then it can be raised again and they will pay more attention on the road.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
RkDg_Crayon Disputed
0 points

But some peeps might not think of that and just drive like a 16 year old

Side: Leave as is
kadenkemp(6) Disputed
1 point

There are around 5,000 teenager deaths from crashes each year.

In 2003, 937 16 year old lives were lost in motor vehicle accidents. 411 were operating the vehicle. The other 352 were the passengers to drivers under the age of 18.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
Robb(2) Disputed
1 point

But driving is, after all, a skill like any other; it is not mastered overnight — or after a few weeks of classroom instruction and a couple of hours in the seat. Therefore, it takes time to learn so it might be easier to teach kids to drive at 14 or 15 and then let them actually start to drive at the age of 17 or 18 so they know what they are doing.

Side: Raise the Driving Age
-1 points

If the driving age is raised then 18 year olds will also crash because of inexperience. This means that the death rate of 18 year olds will increase, while the death of 16-year-old death rate; will increase. We are not helping the cause by raising the driving age we are just delaying the time they will die.

Side: Leave as is
-1 points

If the driving age is raised then 18 year olds will also crash because of inexperience. This means that the death rate of 18 year olds will increase, while the death of 16-year-old death rate; will increase. We are not helping the cause by raising the driving age we are just delaying the time they will die.

Side: Leave as is
-1 points

If the driving age is raised then 18 year olds will also crash because of inexperience. This means that the death rate of 18 year olds will increase, while the death of 16-year-old death rate; will increase. We are not helping the cause by raising the driving age we are just delaying the time they will die.

Side: Leave as is
SCM26(2) Disputed
1 point

You are so wrong, it protects us from car crashes and other things

Side: Raise the Driving Age